I come from a very Italian family. Growing up on Long Island, so many of my memories center around food—shared meals for every occasion. Now that we live in Florida, that tradition continues at Carmelo’s Italian Ristorante in Punta Gorda. We’ve celebrated engagements and held rehearsal dinners there. I’ve been with my boyfriend’s family, who’ve been going there since the original location opened on West Olympia Avenue 11 years ago. We take visitors when they’re in town. I just keep going back.
Carmelo’s is run by an Italian family, and it mirrors the experiences I had growing up in a home where holidays are celebrated with passed-down recipes so they stay with us. You can taste that someone was up early making the sauce and baking bread, the same way that I remember my grandmother doing.
Chef-owner Carmelo Mangiafico is on the line six days a week, running a fully scratch kitchen. The meatballs, sausage and soup are made fresh, like the ones I grew up with. The fresh pasta comes from a company in West Palm Beach. His father-in-law often works as the maître d’, and his cousin, a pastry chef, makes trays of cakes and classic Italian desserts that they bring from table to table after dinner.
1 of 2
Photography by Anna Nguyen
carmelos defines italian tradition punta gorda exterior
Nestled in Punta Gorda’s historic district, Carmelo’s Italian Ristorante’s quaint charm and Old World traditions mesh with the fully scratch kitchen. Dishes like shrimp and scallop limoncello keep tables full.
2 of 2
Photography by Anna Nguyen
carmelos defines italian tradition punta gorda exterior
When we go as a group, we start off with two pitchers of the tableside sangria. The server smashes the oranges, lemons and limes right there, then adds a couple of different spirits and Sangue di Giuda, a sweet Italian red wine. I know you’re not supposed to pair sangria with chicken parmesan, but it does wonders for me. We get an antipasti plate for the table and the Pasta Bada Bing, the signature dish, which is flambéed at the table by Carmelo’s 74-year-old father, Ernesto, then tossed in a giant wheel of Grana Padano cheese. It’s such an experience. You see flames flaring throughout the dining room all night as other tables order it, too.
During season, you have to make a reservation. We always sit on the garden patio, which is gorgeous and has live music most nights. The restaurant moved to a 1920s home in the historic district several years ago, keeping the original building’s character and adding murals of Italian landmarks, including the cathedral in Ortigia, where Carmelo was born.
Punta Gorda was wrecked by back-to-back hurricanes in 2024. Our house was flooded, and so much of downtown was gutted. Seeing Carmelo’s standing—and full—life feels normal again.
1 of 2
Photography by Anna Nguyen
carmelos defines italian tradition punta gorda exterior
2 of 2
Photography by Anna Nguyen
carmelos defines italian tradition punta gorda chef
Chef-owner Carmelo Mangiafico pilots the line six days a week, working alongside family members who help manage the restaurant, bake trays of desserts and prep dishes tableside.